Specific Indicators of Root Development

To determine if your rose cutting has rooted, look for the following indicators:
Visual Signs
One of the most reliable signs is the appearance of new growth, such as tiny pink new leaves or an increase in the size and vigor of the existing leaves. This usually indicates that the cutting has developed a robust root system[3][4][5].
Resistance to Tugging
Gently tug on the cutting after a few weeks. If you feel resistance, it suggests that roots have formed and are anchoring the cutting in the soil[1][2][5].
Callus Tissue Formation
In the early stages of rooting, a callus (a mass of undifferentiated cells) will form at the base of the cutting. This is a precursor to root development and can be observed after a few weeks[2][3].
Leaf Color and Texture
Healthy, rooted cuttings will have leaves that remain vibrant and do not wilt excessively. If the leaves start to wilt and do not recover with watering, it may indicate poor root development[1][3][4].
Timeframes for Rooting

The time it takes for rose cuttings to root can vary depending on the type of rose and the conditions:
Softwood Cuttings
These typically root within 2-4 weeks during late spring and early summer[1][4].
Semi-hardwood Cuttings
These may take 4-6 weeks to root, usually in late summer and early fall[1][2].
Hardwood Cuttings
These are the slowest, often taking 12 weeks or more to root, typically in late fall or early winter[1][5].
Recommended Methods for Testing Root Growth
To test for root growth without disturbing the cutting, you can use the following methods:
Tugging Test
As mentioned earlier, gently tug on the cutting to feel for resistance, which indicates root formation[1][2][5].
Observation Through Transparent Bags
If you are using the \”doggybag\” or ziplock bag technique, you can observe roots developing through the transparent plastic[3].
Checking for New Growth
Monitor the cutting for new leaves or increased leaf size and vigor, which are signs of successful rooting[3][4].
Optimal Environmental Conditions
For optimal rooting, rose cuttings require specific environmental conditions:
Temperature
Cool to moderate temperatures are best. For example, late fall and early winter (around 40°F to 60°F or 4°C to 15°C) are favorable for rooting[2][3][5].
Humidity
High humidity is crucial, especially during the initial stages of rooting. Using a glass jar or a plastic bag to cover the cuttings can help maintain humidity[2][3].
Light
Bright, indirect light is ideal. Direct sunlight, especially during hot afternoons, should be avoided. East or north-facing locations are recommended[2][3][5].
Common Challenges and Solutions
Common challenges during the rooting process include:
Drying Out
Ensure the cuttings remain moist but not soggy. Water every other day if necessary, and use a well-draining rooting medium[2][3][5].
Extreme Temperatures
Protect the cuttings from extreme heat or cold. In hot conditions, use ice or cool storage to keep the cuttings cool until they are planted[2][3].
Inadequate Humidity
Use techniques like covering the cuttings with a glass jar or plastic bag to maintain high humidity[2][3].
Root Rot
Avoid overwatering and ensure the rooting medium drains well. A blend of peat moss and perlite is often recommended for its moisture retention and drainage properties[5].
Reference:
[1] GardenTech: [Reproduce and Grow Roses From Cuttings – GardenTech][1]
[2] Aggie Horticulture: [Rose Propagation by Dr. William C. Welch – Aggie Horticulture][2]
[3] Heritage Roses: [Rose Propagation – Ziplock Bag Technique][3]